Fitness Freedom: Exercise Without Obsession

In this episode, we’ll uncover the problem with obsessive fitness culture, introduce the Health at Every Size (HAES) philosophy, share practical tips for finding your fitness joy, and hear real-life stories of people who’ve embraced a more joyful approach to exercise. Plus, I’ll share how you can create a supportive fitness community and connect with like-minded individuals. Let’s get started!

Listen Now

Welcome to another empowering episode of “Say When!” I’m your host, Holly Toscanini, and today we’re talking about something many of us struggle with: “Fitness Freedom: Exercise Without Obsession.” We’ll be exploring how to shift our focus from weight loss to joy and well-being when it comes to fitness.

Before we go any further I want to issue a Disclaimer: This podcast is for educational purposes only and does not substitute for professional medical advice. Always consult with a healthcare provider before starting any new exercise program.

Now that we have that out of the way…

I remember my early days at the gym, meticulously counting every calorie burned and checking the scale with an intensity that could probably rival a NASA launch. But let’s be honest, the only thing I was launching was myself into a cycle of guilt and frustration. Somewhere between the treadmill sprints and the endless crunches, I forgot why I even started exercising in the first place—to feel good! So, today, we’re throwing out the scale and reclaiming our right to move our bodies in ways that bring us joy and fulfillment.

Now that we have that out of the way…

Let’s take a deeper look at societal pressures and how they shape our views on fitness. It’s no secret that society often equates fitness with thinness. This equation is not just pervasive but insidious, affecting how we see ourselves and how we believe others see us. From magazine covers and TV commercials to social media and celebrity culture, the message is clear: being fit means being thin.

Consider the constant barrage of ‘before and after’ photos. These images are designed to sell the idea that thinner is better, more desirable, and ultimately healthier. They show dramatic transformations that are often achieved through extreme diets and grueling exercise routines, creating an unrealistic standard for the average person. The underlying message is that your worth is tied to your ability to conform to a particular body ideal.

Weight loss success stories are another tool in this societal toolkit. These stories are frequently celebrated, shared, and held up as examples of willpower, determination, and success. Yet, they rarely show the long-term sustainability of these weight loss methods, nor do they discuss the potential physical and mental health consequences. The narrative focuses solely on the external change, reinforcing the idea that our external appearance is paramount.

Fitness influencers also play a significant role in this dynamic. With their toned bodies, perfect poses, and polished lifestyles, they set a standard that can be nearly impossible to attain without significant resources and time. These influencers often promote the latest diets, supplements, and exercise regimes, contributing to a culture of comparison and competition. Their influence is so pervasive that it can make anyone feel like their worth is tied to their waistline.

But here’s the kicker—fitness isn’t about shrinking yourself; it’s about expanding your joy, strength, and well-being. This societal fixation on thinness distracts us from the true benefits of physical activity. Exercise should be about how it makes you feel, not how it makes you look. When we focus solely on aesthetics, we miss out on the myriad of mental, emotional, and physical benefits that come from engaging in regular physical activity.

The impact of these societal pressures can be profound. Many of my clients have shared stories of anxiety, low self-esteem, and even disordered eating behaviors, all stemming from the pressure to achieve a ‘perfect’ body. These pressures are not just external; they become internalized, leading us to believe that our value as individuals is directly linked to our appearance. This belief can set us up for a lifetime of dissatisfaction and self-criticism, as we constantly strive to meet an ever-changing and unattainable ideal.

Psychological Impact

The emotional toll of weight-focused fitness is significant. When we tie our self-worth to our physical appearance, we set ourselves up for a cycle of perpetual disappointment. For instance, consider the emotional roller coaster that accompanies dieting. There are the initial highs of seeing the scale move downward, followed by the inevitable lows when weight loss plateaus or reverses. This constant fluctuation can lead to feelings of failure, shame, and inadequacy.

Many of my clients have experienced these emotions firsthand. They’ve shared stories of how societal pressures have led them to engage in extreme dieting and exercise regimens, only to end up feeling worse about themselves. The pressure to achieve a ‘perfect’ body can lead to a host of negative emotions, including anxiety and depression. It can also contribute to disordered eating behaviors, such as restrictive dieting, binge eating, and compulsive exercise.

When we prioritize weight loss over well-being, we ignore the broader aspects of health. True health encompasses physical, mental, and emotional well-being. It’s about feeling strong, energetic, and capable. It’s about having a positive relationship with food and exercise. And most importantly, it’s about feeling good in your own skin, regardless of your size or shape.

Expert Insight

Research supports the negative effects of fitness obsession. A study published in the International Journal of Eating Disorders found that individuals who focus on weight loss as a primary goal for exercise are more likely to experience body dissatisfaction and disordered eating behaviors. This study highlights the dangers of a weight-centric approach to fitness and underscores the importance of promoting exercise for health and enjoyment rather than weight loss (Bennett et al., 2017).

Further research in the field of body image and exercise psychology reveals that individuals who engage in physical activity for intrinsic reasons—such as enjoyment, stress relief, or social connection—are more likely to maintain a consistent exercise routine and experience positive mental health outcomes. On the other hand, those who exercise primarily to change their appearance often experience lower self-esteem and higher levels of body dissatisfaction.

These findings emphasize the need to shift our focus from weight loss to overall well-being. When we engage in physical activity for the joy of movement and the benefits it brings to our lives, we are more likely to stick with it in the long term. Exercise should be a source of pleasure and self-care, not a punishment for our bodies or a means to fit into societal norms.

In conclusion, societal pressures to equate fitness with thinness can have detrimental effects on our mental and emotional well-being. By shifting our focus to the joy and benefits of physical activity, we can create a healthier, more sustainable approach to fitness. Let’s reclaim fitness as a source of empowerment, joy, and well-being, free from the shackles of societal expectations.

HAES and the Joyful Approach to Exercise

Let’s talk about Health at Every Size (HAES), a philosophy that’s truly a breath of fresh air in a world obsessed with dieting and weight loss. HAES promotes the idea that people of all shapes and sizes can pursue health and well-being through behaviors like intuitive eating and joyful movement, without focusing on weight loss as a primary goal. It’s a radical shift away from the idea that you need to change your body to be healthy. Instead, it celebrates diversity and encourages us to find ways to care for our bodies that feel good and are sustainable.

Exercise as Enjoyment

One of the core principles of HAES is finding joy in movement. Imagine, instead of dragging yourself to the gym because you feel like you have to, you actually look forward to moving your body because it feels good. This means discovering physical activities that you genuinely enjoy and that make you feel good. For some, it might be dancing in your living room, letting the music guide you and feeling the freedom in your movements. For others, it could be hiking in nature, where the beauty of your surroundings and the fresh air rejuvenate you. Or maybe it’s simply taking a leisurely stroll in your neighborhood, enjoying the sights and sounds around you. The goal is to move in ways that bring you pleasure and enhance your overall well-being, rather than feeling like a chore or punishment.

Alignment with Body Acceptance

This joyful approach to exercise aligns perfectly with my coaching philosophy. I often recommend activities like yoga and walking because they not only promote physical health but also encourage mindfulness and body awareness. Yoga, in particular, is a fantastic way to connect with your body, improve flexibility, and reduce stress. There’s something incredibly powerful about tuning into your breath and moving through poses that honor your body’s capabilities. Walking, on the other hand, is accessible, gentle on the joints, and a great way to enjoy the outdoors. It’s about finding what works for you and embracing it wholeheartedly.

Practical Tips for Fitness Freedom

Finding Your Fitness Joy

Next, listen to your body. Pay attention to how different activities make you feel. Do you feel energized and happy after a dance class? Or calm and centered after a yoga session? Let your body guide you. It knows what it needs and what feels good.

The first step towards fitness freedom is discovering what types of exercise feel good for your body. You might want to experiment with different activities. Try out various forms of exercise until you find something you love. It could be swimming, where the water supports you and you feel almost weightless as you move. Or maybe dancing, where you lose yourself in the rhythm and let your body express itself freely. Biking could be your thing, feeling the wind on your face and the sense of adventure. Or perhaps yoga, where the focus is on mindful movement and breath. The key is to be open and curious.

And remember, prioritize fun. Choose activities that you enjoy and that make you feel good, rather than those that you think you ‘should’ do. Exercise shouldn’t feel like a punishment or a chore; it should be something you look forward to because it brings you joy and makes you feel alive.

Mindful Movement

Incorporating mindfulness into your fitness routine can enhance your overall experience. Focus on the present moment. Pay attention to your breath, your body’s movements, and how you feel during exercise. This can help you stay present and fully engage in the activity. It’s about being in the moment and really experiencing the joy of movement.

Set an intention before you start exercising. This could be something like “I want to feel energized” or “I want to connect with my body.” Setting an intention can give your workout purpose and help you stay focused on what really matters—how you feel, rather than how you look.

And be kind to yourself. Practice self-compassion and avoid self-criticism. Remember that fitness is not about perfection but about taking care of yourself. It’s okay to have days when you don’t feel like exercising, and it’s okay to take it easy when you need to. Listen to your body and honor its needs.

Inclusion and Accessibility

Fitness should be accessible and enjoyable for all body types and abilities. This means adapting exercises to suit your body’s needs and capabilities. For example, if you have joint issues, consider low-impact activities like swimming or chair yoga. These activities can provide the benefits of movement without putting too much strain on your body.

Seek supportive environments. Look for fitness classes and groups that promote body positivity and inclusivity. Being in a supportive environment can make a significant difference in your fitness journey. It can help you feel accepted and motivated, knowing that you’re surrounded by people who respect and support you.

Use assistive devices if needed. Don’t hesitate to use tools like resistance bands, yoga blocks, or mobility aids to support your movements. These devices can help you modify exercises to make them more comfortable and effective for your body.

By embracing the principles of HAES and focusing on joyful movement, you can create a more positive and sustainable relationship with fitness. It’s about finding what works for you, enjoying the process, and celebrating what your body can do, rather than punishing it for what it isn’t. Let’s make fitness a source of joy and well-being, not a source of stress and self-criticism.

Real-Life Stories and Successes

I’d like to share the story of my client, Emily. Emily had been caught in the cycle of yo-yo dieting and intense workout regimens for years. She felt exhausted and defeated, believing she would never achieve the ‘ideal’ body. When Emily joined my program, we focused on finding joy in movement. She discovered a love for yoga and regular walks. Emily shared that these activities not only made her feel physically stronger but also brought her a sense of peace and happiness she had never experienced before.

“I used to think of exercise as a punishment, a way to earn my food by burning off calories. It was a constant battle, and I never really enjoyed it. I tried yoga and other group classes, but nothing clicked. I always loved swimming, but the thought of putting on a swimsuit and heading to the pool made me too self-conscious. I felt trapped in my bigger body, convinced that everyone would judge me.

Then I started coaching with Holly, and everything changed. She helped me shift my mindset and feel neutral about my body. Holly taught me the importance of self-compassion and showed me that my worth isn’t tied to my appearance. With her guidance, I gradually became more comfortable in my own skin.

One day, I finally mustered the courage to put on a swimsuit and head to the pool. I was nervous, but I remembered Holly’s words and focused on the joy of swimming rather than the fear of judgment. Now, I swim twice a week, and it’s become one of the highlights of my routine. I feel strong, happy, and free. Thanks to Holly, I’ve found a way to move my body that brings me genuine joy and well-being.” – Lisa

Overcoming Challenges

Overcoming fitness obsession and finding joy in movement can be challenging, but it’s entirely possible. I’ve seen many clients break free from the grip of obsessive exercise and embrace a more balanced, joyful approach. These stories of transformation are a testament to the power of shifting our mindset and focusing on well-being rather than weight loss.

One common challenge is letting go of the belief that exercise must be intense or punishing to be effective. Many people feel that if they’re not sweating buckets or pushing their limits, they’re not working hard enough. However, this mindset can lead to burnout, injury, and a negative relationship with exercise. It’s important to remember that any movement is beneficial and that consistency matters more than intensity. Finding activities that you enjoy and can sustain over the long term is key.

Another challenge is dealing with the guilt and shame that often accompany missed workouts or indulgent meals. Many of us have been conditioned to see exercise as a way to ‘earn’ food or ‘make up for’ eating. This creates a toxic cycle of punishment and reward that can take the joy out of both eating and exercising. Instead, try to view exercise as a form of self-care and a way to feel good, rather than a means of burning calories. This shift in perspective can help you develop a healthier, more positive relationship with movement.

Finally, it can be difficult to navigate the societal pressures and cultural messages that equate fitness with thinness. Everywhere you look, there are ads, social media posts, and well-meaning friends and family members promoting the idea that losing weight is the ultimate goal of exercise. It’s crucial to challenge these messages and remind yourself that fitness is about health, strength, and happiness, not size. Surrounding yourself with supportive, like-minded individuals can make a big difference in maintaining this mindset.

Creating a Supportive Fitness Community

Encouraging Acceptance

Building a supportive fitness community starts with encouraging acceptance—acceptance of our bodies and the bodies of others. Imagine a space where everyone feels welcome, regardless of their size, shape, or fitness level. This kind of environment can be incredibly empowering and motivating.

One way to foster this acceptance is by promoting body neutrality. Encourage a neutral body image and celebrate all body types. This might mean featuring diverse body types in your marketing materials, using inclusive language, and actively challenging harmful stereotypes. When people see that all bodies are valued and celebrated, they’re more likely to feel comfortable and confident in their own skin.

Practicing non-judgment is also essential. Create a space where people feel safe and accepted, regardless of their fitness level or appearance. This means avoiding comments or behaviors that could make someone feel self-conscious or inadequate. Instead, focus on supporting each individual’s unique journey and celebrating their progress, no matter how small.

Sharing stories can also help build connection and understanding. Share your own journey and invite others to do the same. This can help break down barriers and foster a sense of community. When people see that they’re not alone in their struggles and that others have overcome similar challenges, it can be incredibly inspiring and motivating.

Connecting with Like-minded People

Connecting with like-minded people can enhance your fitness journey in countless ways. It can provide support, motivation, and a sense of belonging. Here are some tips for finding supportive fitness groups:

Start by looking for HAES-aligned classes. These communities often prioritize well-being and joy over weight loss, making them a great fit for anyone looking to embrace a more positive, balanced approach to fitness. Whether it’s a yoga class, a walking group, or a dance class, finding a community that shares your values can make a huge difference in your fitness journey.

Attending workshops and events focused on body neutrality and joyful movement is another great way to connect with like-minded individuals. These events can provide valuable information, support, and inspiration. Plus, they’re a great way to meet new people and build your fitness community.

Engaging online can also be incredibly beneficial. Join online communities and forums where you can connect with others who share your values and goals. These spaces can provide support, encouragement, and a wealth of information. Whether it’s a Facebook group, an Instagram community, or a fitness forum, finding your tribe online can be a great way to stay motivated and inspired.

In conclusion, overcoming fitness obsession and finding joy in movement is entirely possible with the right mindset and support. By focusing on well-being rather than weight loss, promoting body positivity and acceptance, and connecting with like-minded people, you can create a fitness journey that is empowering, enjoyable, and sustainable. Let’s celebrate our bodies for what they can do, rather than punishing them for what they aren’t.

Additional Resources

If you’re looking for more resources to support your fitness journey, consider exploring HAES-aligned fitness classes, trainers, and resources. Here are a few recommendations:

1. HAES Community: Check out the HAES Community website for resources, support groups, and events.

2. Body Positive Fitness Alliance: Explore the Body Positive Fitness Alliance for information on inclusive fitness professionals and classes.

3. Books and Podcasts: Read books like “Body Respect” by Linda Bacon and Lucy Aphramor, and listen to podcasts like “Food Psych” by Christy Harrison for more insights on body positivity and joyful movement.

To recap, today’s episode focused on shifting the focus of fitness from obsession and weight loss to joy and well-being. We discussed the problems with obsessive fitness culture, introduced the HAES philosophy, shared practical tips for finding your fitness joy, and heard real-life stories of transformation. Remember, fitness is about feeling good and taking care of yourself, not about achieving a specific body size or shape.

Now that you’re moving your body for the sheer fun and enjoyment of it, are you ready to liberate yourself from diet culture and discover your path to body confidence and intuitive living?

Take my Freedom From Diets Assessment to see where you stand on your journey to breaking free from diet culture. Gain clarity, powerful tools, and personalized directions to transform your beliefs, embrace your body, and trust your intuition.

The Freedom from Diets Assessment is a transformative tool designed to liberate you from diet culture and guide you toward true body peace and food freedom. This personalized journey provides actionable steps tailored to your unique experiences and challenges. Plus, receive a customized coaching video from me with specific guidance and support based on your responses.

Imagine never feeling anxious around food again or lacking the confidence to ask for what you want in life. What if you trusted your intuition and body wisdom at all times? Begin your journey to an enlightened, non-diet lifestyle today!

This assessment can help you uncover your path to fitness freedom and find joy in movement. I also encourage you to share your fitness joy stories with me and sign up for my coaching programs. Together, we can create a community that celebrates well-being and joy in fitness.

I’ll leave you with this thought: Fitness is not about punishing your body for what you ate, but about celebrating what your body can do. So, put on your favorite workout gear, turn up the music, and move in a way that makes you feel alive and joyful. Until next time, stay well, stay joyful, and say when to obsessive fitness!

Thank you for joining me on this journey to fitness freedom. If you enjoyed today’s episode, please subscribe to the podcast, leave a review, and share it with your friends. Let’s spread the message of joyful movement and body positivity far and wide. Take care, everyone!

Connect with Holly: